Conflicts between landlords and tenants are fairly commonplace. There may be disputes about rent, maintenance, noise from a neighbor’s apartment, parking or some other everyday occurrence.
But sometimes tensions surface over larger issues, such as the need for reasonable accommodations for a disability, or the belief that some tenants are given preferential treatment because of their race, color, religion, gender, national origin or familial status. When these types of disputes are not resolved, , they often lead tenants to file complaints with HUD and local fair housing agencies which include the threat of litigation.
In such turbulent times, a mediator can step in to facilitate the parties through the rocky discussions.
Mediators with Fair Housing experience are the unsung heroes of housing disputes, bringing an impartial lens to the table. They are well-versed in the nuances of fair housing laws, making them adept at untangling the knots of contention.
Their role is pivotal: transforming potential legal wars into dialogues leading to resolution. With a mediator’s help, what might have been a drawn-out battle turns into a journey toward mutual understanding and agreement.
Why does this matter? Because at the heart of every dispute is the chance for resolution and growth.
By choosing mediation, both landlords and tenants board a path that is not just about solving a problem, but forging a better way forward together.
How can this approach change the way housing disputes are handled? Let’s explore the transformative power of mediation.
A mediator is an impartial third person with knowledge of the area of law in which the dispute arises who is chosen by the parties to assist in exploring whether the matter can be resolved outside the court system.
Unlike litigation, where the court process is public, mediation provides a private and more expedient way to resolve housing disagreements.
In fair housing disputes, mediators conduct confidential sessions with the view of reaching a resolution through mutual agreements rather than undergoing a lengthy administrative process that eventually might result in a court proceeding.
Let’s focus on how this process unfolds in the context of landlord/tenant disputes.
A dispute may arise when a landlord takes some action against the tenant, such as issuing a Notice to Cure for a lease violation, or posting a Notice of Termination of the lease. If the tenant does not respond in a timely manner (or at all), the landlord may start eviction proceedings. It is always best for the tenant to get legal advice as quickly as possible at this point. Once an eviction proceeding is filed, a tenant must take action to file an answer and raise affirmative defenses. The tenant also may be required to deposit rent in the court registry. Because eviction cases usually are set for trial fairly quickly, this is the time to suggest the parties engage in mediation.
Choosing an impartial and experienced mediator is vital. The mediator ought to have experience both in landlord/tenant statutes and Fair Housing Law. It is also helpful to select a mediator who lives or works in the same community as the parties so that he or she will understand the nuances of the housing market in the area. And, the mediator should also be a person with litigation experience so he or she can explain what typically happens in a court proceeding.
The mediator’s responsibility is to facilitate communication between disputing parties and to conduct the mediation in a way that allows the parties to fully explore settlement options. The mediator also ensures the process is fair to both parties.
Mediators play a pivotal role in helping tenants and landlords reach fair and acceptable settlements that spare the parties the time, expense and frustration of litigation and preserve the landlord-tenant relationship as further explained below.
In addition to helping resolve typical landlord/tenant issues, mediators also can play a pivotal role in settling Fair Housing claims. Let’s use this scenario as an example. A tenant’s lease was terminated because he repeatedly refused to take his garbage to the dumpster. The garbage bags were left in the hallway. His neighbors constantly complained of the smell and sight of garbage and the landlord took action to evict him.
At hearing the tenant claimed that the reason he did not take the trash to the dumpster was because he did not have the bodily strength to carry things when he walked or to open the dumpster. This was not apparent to the landlord because the tenant walked to the office each day to retrieve his mail.
Recognizing that an accommodation might assist the tenant comply with the lease, the court referred the parties to mediation. With the help of a mediator experienced in the area of Fair Housing law, the parties reached a mutual agreement that a member of the landlord’s staff would collect the tenant’s garbage from the hallway twice a week and take it to the dumpster. The mediator’s knowledge of Fair Housing assisted the tenant in remaining a resident, satisfied the neighbors’ concerns about smelly garbage and also helped the landlord comply with his obligations to provide a reasonable accommodation under the Fair Housing Act, 42 U.S.C. §3401 et seq. and HUD’s regulations.
As you can see, mediating Fair Housing disputes has many benefits including the following:
Importantly, unlike litigation, mediation does not require one party to be the winner and one party to be the loser. Indeed, it is not unusual when a mediation is successful for both parties to be unhappy with the resolution of their dispute. Neither party gets exactly what they want, but the dispute is settled.
Mediation empowers parties by giving them a direct say in crafting solutions that meet their needs and interests. Unlike decisions imposed by courts or authorities, mediated agreements are typically reached through consensus, enhancing the sense of ownership and satisfaction with the outcome.
And unlike litigation, mediation proceedings are confidential, which means that discussions and negotiations that take place during mediation are not made public. This confidentiality can encourage parties to engage more openly and candidly in finding solutions.
Finally, mediation helps preserve relationships. Fair housing disputes can be emotionally charged and can strain relationships between parties involved, such as landlords, tenants, or community members. Mediation provides a structured process that allows parties to express their concerns, understand each other’s perspectives, and work towards mutually agreeable solutions while preserving their relationships.
Mediating fair housing disputes is instrumental in promoting fairness, equality, and understanding while offering a practical and effective alternative to traditional legal processes between landlords and tenants.
It’s fair, quick, and respects everyone’s rights. Mediation helps us find the right balance, keeping things private and respectful.
In summary it not only resolves specific conflicts but also contributes to the broader goal of ensuring equitable access to housing for all individuals and communities.
Langbein ADR Services can help you resolve a Fair Housing dispute with your current or former landlord before the need to navigate the administrative maze at HUD or a local fair housing agency OR get us involved while your claim is being investigated. Consider Langbein ADR Services before you become enmeshed in long, tiring, expensive litigation.
Contact Us Today for a Consultation – Let Peace of Mind Prevail
